Ask me anything

RSS Feed
  1. All responses Most smiled responses
    1. Troy Goodfellow

      I wish, but not very likely. Too many other teams between them and 8th place. If they had a good goalie and a stronger blueline corps, I think they could do it next year.

    2. Troy Goodfellow

      I have had coffee with Tom. I can't remember if he ever fetched it for me. We need to work on this, obviously.

    3. Troy Goodfellow

      Probably Dominion, since it is fast and I think there are still lots of cool combos yet to be discovered.

      Choosing between Tom and Bruce is pretty easy, since Bruce won't make stupid jokes about how lame sports are. In boardgaming, the game is often secondary to the conversation around it.

    4. Troy Goodfellow

      I've been playing CK2 since the beta, and I love it. It was stable and enjoyable even when most of the events were still unwritten. They even worked at getting the tip/advice text in place very early.

      I have only dabbled in House Divided. So far, I like the challenges, especially the War Justification thing which lets you try to manufacture a casus belli but with the caveat that if you are discovered ginning things up you take an infamy hit.

    5. Troy Goodfellow

      Lots of good board gaming blogs and podcasts. Hard to choose my favorites, since I don't listen to as many podcasts as I would like.

      I recommend Michael Barnes' Cracked LCD column over at Gameshark.com (as well as what he writes at No High Scores).

      Shut Up and Sit Down is a good blog that is centered on what is really a quite good and getting better series of video reviews. Quintin Smith and Paul Dean do it, and I like it very much.

    6. Troy Goodfellow
    7. Troy Goodfellow
    8. Troy Goodfellow

      Maybe. But you also have to consider Go, and Civilization and Diplomacy.

      We can agree that the answer is not Stormrise.

      Chess has a couple of advantages over most modern strategy games. First, it is ubiquitous because, like soccer, once you know the rules you need minimal material to actually play. 32 pieces that can be distinguished and a 64 tile board. Second, it has very simple rules that quickly spiral into an infinite depth of possible positions. There are stronger and weaker openings, of course, but there is something to be learned from all of them.

      Chess's major weaknesses vis a vis modern strategy games are a reflection of its age. First, you have perfect information as a player - you always know everything your opponent has. You may not know what he/she is planning on doing with the material, but you have perfect information to judge that from and there is only a single opponent to evaluate. Second, it is limited to two players so you always have the same object.

      These are not really big deals in the long run. I have wanted to return to chess for a while, and a recent documentary on Bobby Fischer has fired me again. It is a game that has withstood challenges from other games for many reasons, but its core beauty as a design is the foremost.

    9. Troy Goodfellow
    10. Troy Goodfellow
    11. Troy Goodfellow

      Never write a community off - if they were fans of things you did, they may come back. So win them, of course. But don't do things just for the sole purpose of making them feel better; stick with your game design.

      And Napoleon's Campaigns 2 may look like a Paradox design, but it's True AgeOD in most of its design elements (leadership, different levels of command, etc.) It is a wargame, not an empire management game.

    12. Troy Goodfellow

      I think it will be great. Still a long way off, but the Clauswitz engine makes everything look great and clear. And Pdox France/Ageod has sacrificed none of the army management stuff that makes their games so special.

      Disclaimer: Nap Camp 2 is an Evolve client

    13. Troy Goodfellow
    14. Troy Goodfellow
    15. Troy Goodfellow
    16. Troy Goodfellow
    17. Troy Goodfellow
    18. Troy Goodfellow

      Best of New Brunswick? Does leaving count? Seriously, the outdoors is probably the best part of NB beyond the people. Lots of spaces to cross country ski, snowmobile, hike, canoe, camp, etc. I'm not really an outdoor person, but I do miss the solitude of the forest and the sound of the river sometimes.

      Best of Canada is me.

    19. Troy Goodfellow

      Yeah, I've played them and I like them a lot. The SSG games are brilliantly designed, good AI, clear objectives and quite a good UI for a deep wargame. Highly recommended.

    20. Troy Goodfellow

      We have done gateway games in general on the podcast. But this week's 3MA will be about Unity of Command, which I think is a great new gateway wargame about the Stalingrad campaign. From there, I think, you will be able to pick up on Operational Art of War or the Tiller Squad Battle Games.

Troy Goodfellow

Toronto, ON, Canada

www.flashofsteel.com

friends
smiles
16 all-time

Troy Goodfellow’s Bio

Blogger, freelance writer, podcaster, PR guy, strategist, tactician, friend, editor, guy

Advertisement

Who made Troy Goodfellow smile

  • Kieron Gillen
  • Chris Remo
  • Dave 'Fargo' Kosak
  • Dan Amrich
  • Dan Stapleton
  • Ben Kuchera
  • Nadia
See all »

Who Troy Goodfellow responded to

  • Patrick McNally
  • punning pundit
  • Brandon Dawson-Kevin LaRocque
  • RalphTrickey
  • Christopher
  • Josh Hall
  • Dan
  • John G
  • Matt Warren
See all »

Who Troy Goodfellow is following

  • Mitch Dyer
See all »

Who is following Troy Goodfellow

  • Christopher Santine
  • TheGameCritique
  • Leslie K Ernest
  • Jaz McDougall
  • Etelmik
  • bobbyknc
  • Thierry Nguyen
  • Lynxara
  • Mitch Dyer
See all »