Any answer I could give to this question is going to be so disappointing, because I rarely ever even try scary food so I would never know if something is in fact good or not. If a food looks unappetizing, then it's pretty guaranteed that it's not going in my mouth.

*Wracks brain*

This is so sad, but my answer would probably be salad. Plain old everyday "everyone-else-in-the-world-eats" salad. Discovering I actually like Caesar salad has probably been my greatest food hurdle to date. I know, how lame.